2005-04-08

THE STRUGGLE FOR ECONOMIC DEMOCRACY: Social democracy and Libertarian Socialism; Successes, Failures and Prospects for the Future


Economist Robin Hahnel in this LONG ESSAY deals with the history of economic democracy.

Hahnel reviews Michael Harrington's analysis of the success and shortcomings of Social Democracy in the 21st century. Like Harrington, he believes that the membership of these parties remained radical yet their leadership lost touch with their base and became electoralist professionals that managed the system (in a more humane way) rather than transform it. The French and Swedish case studies are looked at in more detail as well as the radical proposal of what was called the Meidner Plan, which was the most far reaching proposal of worker's control that a Keynesian state ever contemplated.

Hahnel also looks at the tradition of Libertarian Socialism (i.e. Anarcho-syndicalism or Anarchism). He tries to analyze why this movement disappeared and why it has reappeared in the last decade as a new global force. Hahnel looks into the Libertarian Socialist model that was set up in Spain during the civil war. Orwell and Chomsky have written extesnively about events in Catalonia in the late 30s and have argued that what the anarchist Confedetation of National Labour (CNT) set up was the only true model of real socialism (i.e. an economy controlled by workers, consumers and citizens without capitalists, bosses, party commissars or state bureaucrats).

Hahnel studies these two important movements and their relationship to the various strands of Communism (Soviet, Trotskyism, Euro-Communism, Neo-Marxism etc.)

Hahnel aslo looks at the influence that the New Left, Feminism and Environmentalism had on the vision of Economic Democracy.

Most importantly, yet, this may interest American Economic Democrats more -given the fact that the examples are US based- Hahnel looks into the prospects of a movement for Economic Democracy in the next century by taking into consideration the struggles of the last century as well as new movements. Of course, there is a strong emphasis on the Cooperative sector, which along with the labour movement will be the backbone of an ECODEMA movement.

I hope you find this essay useful in understanding the history and struggles for Economic Democracy as well as its prospects for the future.






COMMENTAIRES

Merci pour la référence, c'est super comme analyse!

Par Pierre Ducasse le 2005-04-08 15:37

Thanks, Tom. I'll definitely be looking over that particular work.

Tom, I'm glad you used the phrase "ECODEMA movement." That is very much what I want to see ECODEMA become....a social movement. A social movement with an active political wing and an economic wing. A social movement that can transcend national borders, language and cultural differences...and even pull the level of political discourse out of the mire that it is presently in.

A tall order, I know. Lots of work to do for the next generation I suppose.

Regards
Alan Avans
Prairie Village KS

Par Alan Avans le 2005-04-09 11:48

Very interesting article. Well balanced approach to both social democracy and anarchism. Hopefully an article such as this will lead to further discussion and help create a practical movement which builds on the strengths of both ideologies. My onmly major difference of opinion is about the notion of revolutionary reforms - I still think they can exist, and believe that any reform that genuinely empowers working people is revoolutionary. (Of course, as the article points out we haven't seen many of these.)

Par Larry Gambone le 2005-04-09 18:26



AJOUTER UN COMMENTAIRE:
Nom:


Courriel:


URL:


Commentaire:


Retranscrivez ces chiffres s.v.p. :


Conserver les informations?