2008-11-06

Are we (really) all socialists now?


In this fascinating article in Time magazine, the author argues that some "state controlled" economies are sometimes better at responding to crisis than democratic states.

However, I want to emphasize that here, on this website, we DO NOT promote state control or ownership of a majority of economic activity. We much prefer coops and others means of true economic democracy. So, to the question of the author : "Are we all socialists now?", I would need to answer that sadly not.

The current financial and economic crisis does demand that we look at things differently. But let's be clear : the partial nationalization of a few banks (as in Great Brittan) was not to fundamentally change capitalism, but to save it. But at least, we won one thing : the idea that government intervention and regulation is necessary, and that the capitalist market doesn't always know best.






COMMENTAIRES

J'aurais aussi dû souligner à quel point cet article démontre à quel point le capitalisme économique peut très bien coexister avec l'autoritarisme politique.

Par Pierre Ducasse le 2008-11-07 09:28

I personally cringe at the thought of state ownership of anything. The essense of socialism is encouragement of social ownership and the unconditional defence of the Commons, which can take a variety a forms, the least desirable forms often involving state ownership.

Par Alan Avans le 2008-11-26 10:10

I is so absurd this day and age that statism is still being portrayed as socialism. It was understandable, say 50 years ago when Stalinism and Fabianism were the basically the only games in town. But since then a host of cooperative, self-managed or workers power concepts of socialism have developed, to the point that even the ex-Stalinist parties talk of an economy worker and community control. I think we have to see the equation "socialism = statism" as part of a propaganda struggle against people like ourselves. Of course, no one wants Big Government bureaucracy and if socialism can be equated with this, people will find the notion undesirable and sink back into lassitude and acceptance of capitalist authoritarianism.

Par Larry Gambone le 2008-11-28 14:43

In the course of our work in the Kansas City and Austin TX areas I've found it helpful to speak to my fellow USAmericans in terms of reinforcing our political republic with an economic democracy, both of which could use the same pattern of constitutional checks and balances. It's pretty simple really. Whoever has control of the economic rudder can steer the entire political ship. Getting control of that economic rudder requires social movement that can act on its agenda....an agenda that can be worked out in the marketplace itself, 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. This has taken place, as we know, under both adverse and favourable conditions and results in the functional prototypes that ought to lead to the design and development of updated models that can stand up 10 ways to Sunday while under heavy scrutiny.

Par Alan Avans le 2009-01-22 15:12



AJOUTER UN COMMENTAIRE:
Nom:


Courriel:


URL:


Commentaire:


Retranscrivez ces chiffres s.v.p. :


Conserver les informations?